Literature Reviews

Review: Who Are Your People by Matthew Macdonald

who are your people

Rating: ★★★★★ (5 stars)

Title: Who Are Your People (Cò As A Tha Thu?)

Poet: Matthew MacDonald

Genre: Poetry

Where to buy: Red Squirrel Press

Summary: A collection of poetry about considering one’s roots.

Content Warnings: alcohol, graveyards, bleeding, death, paternal estrangement, abuse.

My thoughts

Who Are Your People is incredible. I heard some of the poems read aloud, so I connected even more with Matthew MacDonald’s poetry. His poetry is exceedingly precise, sensory, and authentic; as I read the collection, it felt like I was there in those moments.

time and I observe each other

through glass tinted with rain

as we pass, going by other routes

my watch is ticking forward

as I watch the world reverse

– On the Train, p.18

Macdonald’s poem, On the Train, deals with a journey where the speaker contemplates their identity and sense of home. This particular stanza was astounding; the opening line of “time and I observe each other” is profound as time is personified to be almost a witness to the speaker’s journey to their ancestral roots. The final lines of the stanza is incredibly visual, I could see the speaker sitting in the opposite direction to where the train was headed, and how time was racing back to when the speaker last visited; it creates the idea of two different realities/time periods merging together when returning to a familiar place, and I think most people could identify with that.

Continuing this theme of time, the speaker addresses memory entangled with identity:

this is why we came here

to visit the one who remembers you

not as you remember yourself


but as a child, carefree…

– History II – Hillside Cottage, p.30

Trying to remember yourself is a peculiar feeling. This poem is concerned with the speaker as a child in the north of Scotland, and it is quite bittersweet as the speaker is concerned about the changes the cottage has gone through as well as themselves.

Why did I read it?

I had the honour of seeing/meeting Matthew Macdonald at a Neil Hilborn gig. I stumbled upon the merchandise stall and saw an additional poetry book to Neil’s Our Numbered Days, and the title intrigued me so much that I bought it before seeing Matthew’s performance. (He looked surprised, to say the least!)

Does the poet have other works?

You can read more of Matthew MacDonald’s poetry on his website


As a fellow Scot, I connected to the scenery that MacDonald created. If you enjoy reflective, personal poetry about home, then this is for you.

– Melissa Jennings

What is your definition of home?

Let me know!

Connect with me: Twitter / Goodreads / Facebook / Ko-Fi

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s